Hoka cielo x 1

Learn more about the Hoka cielo x 1 male running shoes, including key features, performance, reviews, model updates, and more.

Hoka cielo x 1

Price

$420

Rating

High

Popularity

Very Popular

The Hoka Cielo X 1 is a lightweight, race-focused shoe with a responsive carbon plate, sitting between the speed-oriented Hoka Carbon X series and the more cushioned Hoka Rocket X in the lineup.

6 colorways

Colorway: Virtual Blue/ Cloudless

Widths available: normal

Got a question about the Hoka cielo x 1?
AI-powered

We've got access to 1000s of long-form youtube, google and other Fittir user reviews which means we can answer any question about this shoe. Ask anything, and me and my AI assistant will do our best to answer your question.

Summary

The Hoka Cielo X 1 is a streamlined racing shoe that fits into Hoka's lineup as a high-performance option aimed at runners looking for speed and agility in race situations. This model distinguishes itself with its design focused on weight reduction and responsiveness, making it ideal for competitive runs. Compared to other Hoka models, such as the more cushioned Bondi or Clifton, the Cielo X 1 is less about maximum comfort on long distances and more about enhancing speed and performance. It provides a firmer feel with a breathable upper, offering a locked-in fit, making it suitable for races or faster training sessions. Its minimalist cushioning also sets it apart from the maximalist cushioning trend seen in other Hoka shoes.

Surface

road

Cushioning

MinLowMediumHighMax(42.5mm)

Breathability

LowMediumHigh(Matryx upper)

Weight

263g

Heel-to-Toe Drop

7mm0mm14mm

Support

NeutralLightHigh

Width options

normal

Grip

LowMediumHighMax

Suitability

___% Match

Based on your running profile and intended use, this shoe is a ___% match. Click the dropdowns in each section to learn more.

Based on your running style and needs

▼

Want to know if the Hoka cielo x 1 is right for you?

Our shoe finder is personalised to your needs, and has been used by thousands of runners across the globe.

Get a personalised recommendation

Pros & Cons

AI-powered

Fittir conducts a detailed analysis of the Hoka cielo x 1 to provide you with a comprehensive overview of the shoes features, pros, and cons based on 80 wear-tester reviews.

Summary: The Hoka Cielo X1 is a high-performance racing shoe that excels in comfort, responsiveness, and energy return, making it particularly suitable for long-distance runs and marathons. However, its heavier weight and some design flaws, such as issues with the lacing system and fit, may limit its appeal for elite runners and those seeking a lightweight option for competitive racing..

Most Mentioned Pros

Most Mentioned Cons

cushion
Cushion feeling: Soft

The most common feedback about the shoe's cushioning is that while it offers a lot of comfort, some users find it too soft or mushy, which can negatively impact their running experience.

comfort (9)

energy return (5)

softness (4)

responsive (4)

protection (3)

impact absorption (3)

bounce (2)

balance (2)

Pros

"The shoe provides a lively and bouncy ride, enhancing the overall running experience."

lively

comfortable

bouncy

"The midsole offers excellent bounce and energy return, improving the running experience."

energy return

midsole

bounce

"The Cielo X1 features incredible bounce from its dual PEBA layers."

PEBA

bounce

cushioning

"The Hoka Yell X1 provides excellent bounce and protection during runs."

bounce

protection

"The Hoka C X1 provides excellent bounce and is notably springy from the foam used."

bounce

foam

springy

"Both shoes perform well in terms of bounce and rockers, enabling smoother runs over long distances."

bounce

rocker

long distances

"The shoe offers a significant amount of cushioning which enhances comfort during runs."

cushioning

comfort

bounce

"The shoe offers a bouncy and reactive feel due to the PEBA foam."

cushioning

performance

"The step-in feel of the CLX1 is described as bouncy and fun."

cushion

fun

responsive

"The foam in the shoe provides excellent energy return and responsiveness."

energy return

foam

responsiveness

"The shoe has a very bouncy feel, ideal for fast-paced runs."

bounciness

fast-paced

performance

"The shoe provides a cushioned and bouncy ride that enhances energy return."

bouncy

energy return

cushioned

"The cushioned ride makes recovery runs feel more energetic."

recovery

energetic

cushioned

"The cushioning in the midsole is generous, providing excellent underfoot comfort."

cushioning

underfoot

comfortable

"The shoe's aggressive rocker promotes fast running and makes toe-off swift and springy."

rocker

toe_off

responsive

"The shoe delivers a very protective experience for long-distance running."

cushion

protection

long_distance

"The midsole features an incredibly protective cushioning that enhances comfort during runs."

PEBA foam

midsole

"The shoe features an incredibly protective midsole cushioning that enhances comfort during runs."

PEBA foam

midsole

cushioning

"The shoe features a cushioned midsole that maintains comfort even during fast-paced runs."

cushioning

comfort at speed

"The shoe provides excellent cushioning to reduce soreness during long runs."

cushioning

long runs

soreness

"The shoe features excellent cushioning and responsiveness."

cushioning

responsiveness

"The midsole features advanced cushioning that makes running enjoyable and comforting during different paces."

cushioned

enjoyable

responsive

"The shoe provides excellent cushioning, making it suitable for long runs."

cushioning

long run

comfort

"The shoe has a high level of cushioning that enhances comfort during long runs."

cushioning

long runs

protection

"The midsole cushioning feels the same between both shoes, providing consistent comfort."

cushioning

comfort

midsole

"The midsole offers a comfortable feel with good cushioning."

comfortable

cushioning

"The cushioning in the Skywood X is praised for being unmatched, providing excellent comfort for daily runs."

cushioning

comfort

"The shoe provides excellent cushioning and protection for the legs during long runs."

cushioning

protection

freshness

"It absorbs impact well, making it suitable for hard running sessions."

impact

hard runs

"The cushioning in the shoe effectively absorbs impact, preserving the runner's joints."

joint protection

cushioning

comfort

"The shoes effectively absorb impact, making them comfortable during intense runs."

absorb impact

comfort

intense runs

"The Cielo X1 has a strong capability to handle long mileage thanks to its design."

long runs

bounce

"The shoe provides a super-soft and cushioned feel underfoot, enhancing comfort during runs."

cushioning

bounciness

ride comfort

"The PEBA midsole provides a significant amount of cushioning, making it a comfortable choice for longer runs."

PEBA foam

cushioned

race day

"The squishy Peba midsole provides a bouncy feel that enhances the running experience."

Peba

cushion

bounce

"The foam midsole used in the shoe is recognized to be an industry standard for comfort and performance."

foam

cushioning

industry standard

"The dual density PEBA midsole provides excellent cushioning and support for runners during races."

PEBA

cushioning

compression

"The shoe offers a unique sensation of cushioning that compares favorably to other high-quality racing shoes."

springiness

comparison

cushioning

"The Hoka yellow X1 has a unique midsole design with a mix of foams for comfort and energy return."

energy return

soft feel

"The reviews mention the use of peber-based midsoles in both shoes, which positively influences the running experience by providing adequate bounce."

peber

midsoles

bounce

"The cushioning provided by the PEBA midsole is effective and suits long-distance running."

PEBA midsole

cushioning

long-distance

"The midsole cushioning contributes to an exceptionally comfortable ride."

cushioning

comfort

"The shoe features a dual density midsole that provides appealing cushioning during runs."

cushioning

responsiveness

dual density

"The shoe's midsole is designed with two layers of foam for optimal support."

midsole

stability

support

"The dual density midsole gives a nice balance of comfort and propulsion, ideal for faster runs."

dual density

propulsion

"The cushioned midsole offers good performance for longer distances."

cushioning

marathon

performance

"The Hoka Rocket X2 features a full PEBA midsole which is noted for its cushioning and responsiveness."

cushioning

responsiveness

"The dual-density Peba foam enhances cushioning, offering a plush feel throughout the run."

cushioned

plush

Peba

"The shoe features a significant amount of cushion, enhancing comfort during runs."

comfort

cushion

running

"The shoes provide extreme cushioning, enhancing the overall running experience."

comfort

support

"The C X1 features advanced cushioning for a comfortable ride."

cushion

comfort

long-distance

"The shoe felt very cushioned, making it comfortable during longer runs."

cushioned

supportive

comfortable

"The shoe provides ample cushion for downhill running, ensuring a comfortable experience."

cushion

downhill

comfortable

"The shoe provides an excellent combination of cushioning and stability."

cushioning

stability

"The cushioning in the Alphafly 3 and Hoka C X1 is well-balanced, providing a nice blend of softness and responsiveness during runs."

cushioning

responsiveness

"The cushioning is maximally designed, allowing for increased comfort during runs."

cushioning

comfort

"The carbon plate and foam combination offers great energy return, improving overall performance."

energy return

performance

cushioning

"The energy return and bounce provided by the midsole contribute to a smooth ride during runs."

PEBA midsole

bounce

smooth ride

"The Hoka C X1 features a high-energy return foam which enhances responsiveness during runs."

responsive

cushioning

energy return

"The cushioning provides excellent energy return, contributing to overall performance."

energy return

good propulsion

comfort

"The combination of midsole foams offers a smooth ride and good energy return, making it enjoyable to run in."

midsole

smoothness

energy return

"The cushioning is described as very bouncy, which helps create a dynamic running experience."

cushioning

dynamic

energy

"The midsole provides substantial support that aids in reducing fatigue during long runs."

midsole

comfort

fatigue reduction

"The shoe has an excellent energy return, enhancing the running experience."

energy return

cushion

performance

"The cushioning in the HOKA Cielo X1 is both responsive and abundant, making it comfortable for racing."

responsive

ample

comfort

"The cushioning is responsive and plush, offering comfort and energy return."

cushioning

energy return

comfort

"The dual-density PEBA foam in the midsole provides a soft yet responsive landing, improving overall comfort during high speeds."

midsole foam

cushioning

bounceback

"The unique PEBA foam plush provides a bouncy feeling, contributing to a comfortable ride."

PEBA foam

bouncy

cushion

"The shoe offers bottomless and plush cushioning, making it very comfortable."

plush

comfortable

cushioning

"The midsole has a substantial amount of PEBA foam, promoting a cushioned yet responsive ride."

PEBA foam

cushioning

"The Hoka C X1 offers a nice combination of cushioning and responsiveness, beneficial for long workouts."

cushioning

workouts

"The midsole provides a cushioned yet responsive feel."

responsive

cushioned

"The dual layer midsole with Pebax foam provides a responsive feel."

dual layer

reactive

cushioning

"The midsole foam provides an energy return that is excellent and contributes to the overall responsiveness."

energy return

responsiveness

PEBA foam

"The Cielo X1 offers an incredibly responsive yet cushioned ride."

responsive

cushioning

race day

"The dual density PEBA midsole provides a smooth and forgiving ride, enhancing the overall running experience."

midsole

cushioning

smooth ride

"The Cielo-X1 has an impressive stack height that enhances cushioning during runs."

stack height

cushioning

foam

"The shoe has a high stack height which provides significant cushioning."

high stack

cushioning

comfort

"The cushioning in the shoe remains effective even after extensive use."

cushioning

durability

"The cushioning in the Alphabet 3 feels bouncy, enhancing the running experience."

cushioning

bouncy

"The midsole made of soft and bouncy pea foam provides a unique and enjoyable ride."

pea foam

bouncy

fun ride

"The dual-density foam construction of the midsole strikes a balance between softness and responsiveness."

dual-density

responsive

softness

"A bouncy and responsive ride thanks to the dual-density PEBA foam, making it suitable for faster paces."

responsive

cushioning

bounce

"The shoe provides a fun and stable ride with excellent cushioning."

comfortable

stable

bouncy

"The high stack of foam provides a plush feel, aiding in comfort over long durations."

plush feel

high stack

"The Cellow X1 features an optimal stack height that enhances comfort while still allowing for a racing feel."

stack height

drop

comfort

"The shoe provides a mix of high stack height and cushioning that supports various paces, especially for longer races."

high stack

cushioning

long runs

"The midsole utilizes PeBA foam which is noted for excellent energy return and ride efficiency."

PeBA foam

energy return

efficiency

"The cushioning in both shoes is constructed from PEBA materials, enabling excellent energy return and bounce."

PEBA

bounce

"The shoe's midsole features two layers for a unique feel."

cushioning

layered midsole

"The shoe's cushioning adapts well once pressure is applied, becoming more comfortable."

cushioning

comfort after use

"The foam density feels better suited for the reviewer's running style compared to other recent shoes."

density

structure

comfort

"The shoe has a high stack height, which contributes to its cushioning capabilities."

stack height

cushioning

"The stack height provides an elevated feel that contributes to confidence while running."

stack height

elevation

comfort

"The comfortable midsole materials of the Skywood X (PE foam and super critical EV) enhance the overall running experience."

midsole materials

comfort

"The midsole features top-grade PEBA foam that offers exceptional cushioning while being soft and bouncy."

cushioning

softness

energy return

"The shoes are described as aggressive, cushioned, and comfortable for running."

cushioned

comfortable

aggressive

"These shoes provide more cushioning than previous models, enhancing overall comfort."

cushioning

comparison

"The PEBA midsole offers a combination of lightness and cushioning, making it an ideal race day option."

PEBA foam

bouncy

race day

Cons

"The shoe’s high cushioning can feel mushy, negatively affecting the running experience."

cushion

heel

"The shoe may not provide enough softness for runners who prefer a cushioned feel."

midsole

cushioning

personal preference

"The shoe feels too soft and cushioned for a racing shoe, leading to a relaxed ride."

soft

cushioning

racer

"Some runners might find the shoe unsuitable for their specific recovery run needs due to lack of softness."

recovery runs

softness

cushioning

"The Cloa X1 lacks the expected bounciness of a race day shoe."

softness

bounciness

"While the cushioning is plush, it results in a muted ground feel that may not suit all runners."

cushioning

ground feel

"The SC Elite V4 lacks aggressive cushioning compared to its competitor."

cushioning

comparison

performance

"There's a bounce that can cause discomfort in the knees during runs."

knee discomfort

bounce sensation

"The cushioning in the Endorphin Pro 4 is firmer, which may not appeal to those preferring a softer ride."

cushioning

firmer feel

bounce

"The midsole is noticeably stiff, which could affect flexibility."

stiff

midsole

flexibility

"The shoe could benefit from improved cushioning as it feels quite rigid."

cushioning

rigid

foot strike

"Cushioning may be excessive for marathons, impacting performance."

overcushioned

marathon

performance

"The midsole of the Prime X2 is criticized for not providing distinct advantages in comfort or stability."

similar comfort

no distinct advantage

"The shoe might not have enough cushion for shorter races like 5k or 10k."

10k

shoe weight

cushion

"The initial feeling of the foam was not soft, requiring breaking in."

breaking in

initial feel

"The shoe may be too lightweight for some runners who prefer more substantial cushioning."

lightweight

cushioning

personal preference

"Foam responsiveness in the Cloa X1 may vary with temperature changes."

temperature sensitivity

variability

"The shoe's stack height feels taller than expected, which may affect performance for some runners."

tall stack

performance

feeling

"The shoe prioritizes speed and responsiveness over extra cushioning, which may not suit all runners."

extra cushioning

speed

responsiveness

comfort
Breathability: Less breathable

The most common issues with the shoe's comfort are related to the tongue design and breathability, which were mentioned frequently, indicating they may be significant concerns for users.

tongue (12)

breathability (5)

overall (4)

padding (4)

upper (3)

fit (2)

recovery (2)

insole (2)

Pros

"The shoe's design supports a smooth transition from heel to toe, enhancing comfort during running."

smooth

comfortable

supportive

"The upper construction offers breathability and comfort."

breathable

comfortable

secure fit

"The breathable knit upper keeps the foot comfortably cool during runs."

knit upper

cooling

fit

"The knit upper provides breathability and comfort for long runs."

knit

comfort

breathable

"The shoe has an excellent breathable upper that enhances comfort, especially in warm weather."

breathable

knit upper

"The breathable upper material contributes to comfort, keeping the feet cool during high-intensity runs."

breathable

cool

comfortable

"The upper material breathes well, providing comfort even in colder conditions."

breathable

comfortable

"The breathable knit upper improves overall comfort."

breathable

knit

"The upper is breathable and allows for good airflow, keeping feet cool during runs."

breathable

lightweight

cooling

"The shoe features breathable materials that maintain comfort without overheating the feet during longer efforts."

breathable

cool

long run

"The structure of the material in the SC Elite V4 leads to better breathability compared to the Hoka C LX1."

comfort

breathable

"The knit upper offers breathability and comfort throughout the run."

comfortable

breathable

knit_upper

"The upper of the Rocket X2 is noted for its minimal and breathable design."

lightweight

comfort

fit

"The shoes are very breathable, providing comfort during runs."

breathable

sock-like feel

upper material

"The knit breathable upper provides an impressive level of comfort."

soft

comfortable

breathable

"Many testers found the shoe surprisingly comfortable across different paces."

comfortable

variety

pacing

"The Cielo X1 offers a high level of comfort that surpasses expectations."

comfort

fit

feel

"The shoe provides a great fit once laced correctly, contributing significantly to overall comfort during runs."

comfortable

snug

fit

"The Hoka C X1 offers exceptional comfort and a great fit, particularly for long runs."

comfort

fit

long runs

"The rocker design of the shoe facilitates a comfortable running experience over long distances."

natural

comfortable

long-distance

"The removable insole provides flexibility for runners needing to adjust with custom orthotics."

removable

insole

custom

"Running in the Cielo X1 feels bouncy and enjoyable, making it fun for workouts."

fun

bounce

rhythm

"The Hoka Cielo X1 features a very comfortable knit upper providing a snug fit."

knit

fit

comfort

"The Hoka Cello X1 has a very comfortable upper, surprising for such a stripped-back design."

comfortable

stripped-back design

surprising

"The engineered knit upper provides both structure and comfort, enhancing the overall fit of the shoe."

engineered knit

stiffness

comfort

"The engineered knit upper is comfortable, providing a secure fit without causing irritation."

engineered knit

secure fit

"Comfort is greatly enhanced due to the glove-like fit of the shoes."

fit

upper

comfort

"The gusseted knit tongue adds to the comfort by allowing adjustability."

tongue

adjustable

comfort

"The shoe facilitates recovery for tired legs, making it suitable for longer runs."

comfort

support

"The shoe keeps legs feeling fresh during long runs, aiding recovery."

comfort

long-distance

recovery

"Minimal padding in the heel cup provides a secure fit without excessive bulk."

minimal padding

secure fit

"The shoe offers a comfortable experience during long runs, even on fatigued legs."

long run

bounce

support

"The shoe felt comfortable for long distances even after significant fatigue."

long distance

comfortable

fatigue

"The shoe design allows for a comfortable transition through different phases of running."

transition

comfort

running phases

"The Hoka C X1 has shown great comfort and protection during long runs, making it ideal for marathon training."

comfort

protection

long runs

"The heel design is comfortable and does not irritate the Achilles, which is crucial for runners with sensitive areas."

comfort

heel design

"It effectively minimizes foot fatigue during long durations of wear."

foot fatigue

comfort

long runs

"The Hoka CL X1 has a well-designed upper that minimizes irritation for the Achilles."

irritation

design

comfort

"The Endorphin Pro 4 has a softer midsole, offering comfort for long-distance runs."

softness

bounce

long distance

"The Endorphin Pro 4 provides a natural ride feel for a carbon shoe."

ride

natural

carbon

"Overall, the shoe provides decent comfort, making it suitable for challenging training runs."

comfort

training

endurance

"The shoe has a comfortable upper that locks down securely without irritating the foot."

comfortable

secure fit

no irritation

"The shoe accommodates foot swelling well, making it suitable for longer runs."

swelling

comfortable

long runs

"The shoe provided a really enjoyable experience during the race."

experience

comfort

bounce

"The SC Elite V4 has a softer upper material which enhances overall comfort during runs."

softness

conformity

"The shoe features a soft and smooth ride, enhancing overall comfort during runs."

softness

smooth

comfort

"The shoe's upper is minimal and provides good lockdown without irritation."

comfortable

lockdown

minimal design

"The shoe is structured well, with a thick, supportive upper that aids in comfort during runs."

supportive

comfortable

stable

"It is lightweight, which is beneficial for long runs."

weight

material

"The reviewer recommends the Hoka Cell X1 as a good choice for first marathon shoes, indicating its suitability and comfort for beginners."

marathon

beginner

comfort

"The upper of the Skywood X is described as plush and padded, contributing additional comfort."

upper cushioning

plush

"The Skywood X's lightweight and plush design promotes a fresh feeling in the legs during runs."

leg fatigue

running comfort

"The CLX1 is enjoyable for various running paces and distances without sacrificing comfort."

variety

comfort

enjoyable

"The shoe is a favorable alternative to the Hoka Rocket X, offering more speed and comfort."

comfort

speed

comparative

"Runners experience a springy sensation during runs."

feedback

comfort

springy

"The knit upper offers ease of putting on the shoe compared to other models like the Nike Alphafly."

knit upper

ease of putting on

comfortable

"The attached-tongue design makes it easier to put the shoes on in a hurry during transitions."

attached tongue

ease of use

"The Cielo x1 offers a very smooth and effortless running experience."

softness

effortless

"The shoe allows for a comfortable rolling sensation right from landing."

rolling sensation

easy landing

"The shoe feels amazing right out of the box, highlighting HOKA's commitment to quality."

quality

initial comfort

out of the box

Cons

"The upper material is stiff, making the shoe difficult to put on."

upper

stiffness

"The ride can feel aggressive and may put strain on knees during longer runs."

bounce

knee strain

"The thickness of the tongue adds discomfort and could be improved for a better fit."

thick

discomfort

"The shoe's tongue lacks adequate padding, which is disappointing given its price point."

tongue padding

disappointment

comfort

"The asymmetrical stretchy knit tongue is uncomfortable and does not sit properly on the foot."

uncomfortable

fit

"The asymmetrical tongue is only acceptable, as the reviewer dislikes stretchy knit tongues."

tongue design

stretch

lockdown

"The upper design includes a gusseted tongue that can cause issues."

tongue design

irritation

comfort

"The shoe could cause discomfort if the tongue is not positioned correctly prior to tightening the laces."

irritation

comfort

adjustment

"The stretchy tongue material can bunch up, causing discomfort during runs."

bunching

discomfort

stretchy

"The tongue of the shoe does not sit properly and looks odd when tied."

tongue

fit

odd appearance

"The tongue of the Hoka C X1 tends to bunch up and cause discomfort when worn."

discomfort

stretchy

bulging

"The tongue design is off-center and may cause discomfort during wear."

tongue design

off-center

discomfort

"The tongue is thin and elastic, causing problems when putting the shoes on."

bunching

fit

thin

"The tongue of the Cellow X1 has a stretchy texture that can cause discomfort if not positioned correctly."

tongue

discomfort

fit

"Despite claims of breathability, the upper feels warmer than other options in similar categories."

breathable

hot

"The upper is thick and causes excessive warmth, leading to discomfort during runs."

warmth

upper

discomfort

"The shoe lacks breathability compared to other models."

breathability

comfort

"The shoe lacks breathability, causing it to feel warm."

warm

breathability

"The shoe lacks breathability, causing excessive sweating."

sweating

warmth

training upper

"There is limited cushioning around the heel compared to other HOKA models, which may take time to adjust for some runners."

heel

cushion

adjustment

"The heel cup design may not provide enough padding, risking blisters."

blisters

padding

comfort issue

"The thick upper material may feel too firm for some users, compromising comfort."

firmness

comfort issue

upper material

"The upper material is rigid and uncomfortable, impacting the feel around the forefoot."

rigidity

forefoot

upper material

"The upper's knit material may not be suitable for hot racing conditions."

material

breathability

racing

"Runners may experience soreness in their ankles after using the Cielo X1, indicating a potential issue with comfort."

soreness

initial_use

adaptability

"The heel tab is missing, which is a drawback for a snug-fitting shoe."

heel tab

snug fit

disappointment

"The shoe may not be suitable for longer distances due to potential footstrike issues."

comfort

long_distances

"The shoe's design that forces runners onto their toes may lead to discomfort as mileage increases."

comfort

mileage

"The shoe might not be ideal for those who enjoy a plush feel during easy runs."

comfort

not plush

easier runs

"The shoe lacks a traditional insole, which some runners might find off-putting or uncomfortable."

insole

comfort

"The insole is removable but not meant for custom orthotics."

insole

customization

orthotics

"The shoe has minimal padding in the heel collar, which could affect comfort."

heel collar

comfort

minimalist

"It lacks padding in the upper for added comfort during runs."

padding

upper

comfort

"The Hoka C X1 lacks substantial padding around the Achilles, which could lead to discomfort for some runners."

Achilles

padding

discomfort

"The heel counter lacks sufficient padding, which could be uncomfortable for longer races."

heel counter

padding

hot spots

"The upper material retains sweat, making it heavy."

upper material

sweat retention

"The midsole takes a long time to break in and can feel unyielding."

midsole

break-in

flexibility

"The shoe lacks comfort over long distances due to its aggressive design."

comfort

long-distance

"The Hoka has stiff laces that are not user-friendly."

stiff laces

discomfort

"The laces don't feel comfortable and are hard and dry."

hard

uncomfortable

"The heel cup is irritating, especially at slow paces, which detracts from comfort."

heel cup

irritation

slow pace

"The heel of the shoe feels too hard and fixated."

hard

fixated

"Both shoes have minimal padding around the heel, which might not be sufficient for runners needing extra support."

heel padding

lack of support

"The engineered knit upper is more structured and less comfortable compared to other options."

engineered knit

structure

softness

"The upper material feels too coarse and thick for warm weather."

upper

warm

comfort

"The upper can become uncomfortably warm during runs."

breathability

warmth

"The ankle collar of the Hoka Cellow X1 features a harsh edge that could chafe."

ankle collar

chafing

comfort

"The internal ankle collar caused rubbing during longer distances, leading to discomfort."

rubbing

discomfort

"The ride becomes uncomfortable for slower paces."

comfort

over 8 min/mile

"The shoe feels stiff, which could be uncomfortable for some runners."

stiff

firm ride

"The shoe does not provide enough ground feel when running, making it feel less responsive."

lack of responsiveness

ground feel

"The aggressive rocker design feels awkward when walking or standing still."

awkward design

rocker feel

"The upper of the Cloa X1 feels too substantial for a race day shoe."

substantial

not airy

"The bounce of the shoe could feel excessive for some runners."

excessive bounce

comfort level

"The shoe has a firmer feel than expected, which may not suit everyone's preference for a racing shoe."

foam

softness

personal preference

"Friction from the heel counter caused skin irritation during longer runs."

friction

rubbing

skin irritation

"Some runners may find the carbon fiber plate's rigidity uncomfortable during runs."

carbon fiber plate

discomfort

unforgiving

"The shoe is not as comfortable or efficient at slower paces compared to the previous version."

slow pace

comfort

performance

durability

The main concerns about the shoe's durability are its heavier weight compared to competitors, potential wear on the outsole and foam after limited use, and issues with the exposed materials that may not hold up well over time.

weight (5)

outsole (4)

material (3)

wear (3)

long-lasting (2)

coverage (2)

construction (2)

mileage (2)

Pros

"The durability of the shoe is commendable, showing no visible signs of wear even after extensive use."

durable

wear-resistant

long-lasting

"The shoe has shown excellent durability after extensive use, retaining its bounce and feel even after 210 km."

durability

long-lasting

bounce

"The Cielo X1 is exceptionally lightweight, contributing to its performance as a racing shoe."

lightweight

race-ready

"The overall weight of the shoe is trimmed down effectively without compromising stability."

lightweight

stable

"The shoe is lightweight due to strategic cutouts, making it easier to run faster."

lightweight

carbon-plated

"The weight of the shoe is called chunky, indicating a sturdy construction and possibly better durability."

durability

chunky

construction

"The lightweight design enhances speed and efficiency."

lightweight

efficient

speed

"Noteworthy durability ensures the shoe will last through extensive use, even for competitive runners."

durability

materials

longevity

"The lightweight foam construction adds to its performance characteristics."

lighter materials

foam

carbon fiber

"The outsole rubber coverage is extensive, enhancing durability."

outsole

rubber

coverage

durability

"The Continental rubber used in the Prime X2 Strong is praised for its durability and performance."

durability

Continental rubber

performance

"The Hoka Cielo X1 shows above-average durability for a racing shoe."

durability

racing shoe

super shoe

"The durability of the CIELO X1 is surprising for a lightweight race shoe, surviving extreme conditions."

300 kilometres

weather resistance

durable

"The shoe is designed for long-lasting durability compared to similar racing shoes."

durable

racing shoe

"The rubber coverage on the outsole is excellent, providing good durability."

rubber

outsole

durability

"The SC Elite V4 offers a solid outsole, which contributes positively to the overall performance and durability of the shoe."

durability

outsole

performance

"The shoe's outsole is highly durable and offers substantial protection for extensive mileage."

durable

mileage

protection

"The outsole has sufficient rubber coverage, contributing to its durability over longer distances."

durability

rubber

"The shoe has a durable rubber outsole."

outsole durability

long-lasting

"Durability is a significant advantage due to the ample rubber outsole."

rubber

durability

grip

"The shoe shows minimal wear after 100 miles, indicating its excellent durability."

durable

long lasting

"The shoe features a lightweight design thanks to its unique cutout, contributing to overall speed."

cutout

reduces weight

"The shoe showcases excellent build quality, ensuring it can withstand wear and tear over time."

durable

long-lasting

high quality

"Both shoes are constructed with durable materials, providing confidence during long runs."

durability

long runs

"The shoe has decent rubber coverage on its outsole which aids in durability."

outsole

durability

"The shoe has solid durability thanks to its coverage and construction."

solid construction

coverage

"The shoe has a durable construction that holds up over various runs."

durability

construction

long-lasting

"Constructed with a durable upper material that holds up well during runs."

breathable

durable

"The shoe is durable, maintaining performance even after extensive mileage."

durability

long-lasting

mileage

"Both shoes showcase durability after extensive use without losing performance."

performance

usage

longevity

"The foam in the CLX1 maintains its responsiveness even after extensive mileage."

durability

consistent

long-distance

"The full-length coverage of the sole provides excellent durability and reduces wear on advanced foams."

full-length

durability

advanced foams

Cons

"The shoe is heavier compared to some competitors."

weight

competition

"Some runners may find the shoe heavier compared to other racing options."

heavy

weight weenies

"While it is lighter than many carbon-plated shoes, it is still considered heavier than some alternatives."

lightweight

heavier options

comparison

"The shoe's outsole, while good, could have been made lighter with more aggressive cutouts."

outsole

weight saving

cutouts

"The weight of the shoe may be a drawback for runners looking for a lightweight option."

weight

heavy

"Cutouts in the design can clog up with debris while running on rural roads."

debris

clogging

rural

"The outsole's exposed PEBA material may show wear over time, although durability is above average overall."

wear

durability

outsole

"The shoe may not provide enough durability for everyday training despite being marketed as a race shoe."

durability

value

"The shoe's delicate nature raises concerns for regular use under demanding conditions."

lightweight

durability

performance

"Although they have survived significant wear, this may not be the case for all users in different conditions."

self-reported

personal_experience

"There is some abrasion on the foam after 100 miles, indicating potential durability concerns with long-term use."

foam

durability

abrasion

"The durability of the foam shows signs of breakdown after limited use."

foam

breakdown

"Durability concerns arise regarding the outsole wear, particularly for heel strikers."

outsole wear

heel striker

durability

"The exposed foam at the heel may wear down depending on your running style."

exposed foam

heel strike

wear

"The outsole has exposed midsole parts which may wear down over time and affect durability."

exposed midsole

wear

durability concerns

"The outsole rubber coverage is thinner than the previous version, which raises concerns about durability."

outsole

durability

"The exposed back foam design raises concerns about long-term durability."

exposed foam

design concerns

"The exposed rubber on the outsole of the Hoka C X1 is a design flaw."

exposed

design flaw

"Outsole durability is average as the rubber wears down quickly."

rubber

high wear areas

"There is a lack of rubber coverage on the heel which may lead to quick wear."

lack of rubber

durability

heel wear

"There are concerns about wear on the heel rubber for heavy heel strikers after limited mileage."

heel rubber

durability

"The outsole shows some wear early on after just a few runs, raising concerns about durability."

wear

durability

outsole

"The large cutouts in the outsole may collect debris while running."

outsole

debris

collector

performance
Distance suited: Long (>20km)
Rocker: More rocker

The shoe is frequently noted for being heavy, which may hinder performance, especially for competitive runners, as it appears in over 25% of the reviews.

weight (28)

rocker (14)

responsiveness (8)

speed (5)

efficiency (4)

aggressiveness (4)

energy_return (3)

ride (3)

Pros

"The quick turnover from heel to toe allows for an efficient running stride, making it suitable for long distances."

quick turnover

efficient

long distance

"The shoe enhances the running efficiency and allows for speedy paces."

speed

race

effort

"The pronounced rocker geometry offers an efficient toe-off and improved forward motion during runs."

toe-off

rocker

forward motion

"The shoe allows for efficient energy return, enhancing the overall running performance."

energy return

efficiency

"The shoe is versatile, being effective for both short and long distances."

short distance

long distance

versatile

"The Hoka Yell X1 performs well over various paces, from slow to fast."

performance

range of paces

"The shoe performs well across various paces, making it versatile for different workouts."

varied paces

versatile

"The midsole performance is effective for varied paces during training."

versatile

varied paces

"The shoe is suitable for a range of marathon paces, indicating its versatility for different runners."

marathon

versatile

"The C X1 is designed for versatility, capable of functioning as both a racing shoe and for longer runs."

long runs

racing

versatile

"The shoe is highly versatile, suitable for a range of paces from easy runs to fast sessions."

versatile

easy pace

speed

"The shoe performs well across different types of runs."

performance

variety

"The Hoka C X1 is comfortable and responsive, making it suitable for various paces, including marathon training."

comfort

responsive

marathon

"This shoe is versatile enough for both training and racing purposes."

training

racing

versatile

"The shoes are well-suited for short, medium, and long-distance intervals without any hindrance."

interval training

multi-environment

"The Cielo X1 accommodates a variety of running scenarios, including racing and speed work."

speed work

race day

variety

"The shoe has a lively and energetic ride thanks to the dual foam layers and winged plate."

lively

bounce

energy

"The shoe offers a highly responsive ride that feels bold and bouncy."

responsive

fun

bouncy

"The shoe features a highly responsive dual-layer PEBA midsole."

responsive

midsole

PEBA

"The shoe maintains its responsiveness even over long distances and training runs."

long runs

speed workouts

consistent performance

"The shoe has a unique construction featuring a PEBA midsole and a winged carbon plate that enhances responsiveness."

carbon plate

PEBA

rigid

energetic

"The shoe provides a comfortable yet responsive ride, enhancing running efficiency."

responsive

comfortable

"The shoe offers a highly responsive and bouncy midsole that enhances performance."

responsive

bouncy

marathon

high performance

"The shoe has a good bounce to it, providing an enjoyable and responsive running experience."

bounce

responsive

enjoyable

"The carbon fiber plate enhances toe-off responsiveness, aiding in quick speed transitions."

carbon fiber plate

toe-off

race mode

"The shoe provides outstanding energy return and efficiency during runs."

energy

efficiency

speed

"The carbon plate and PEBA foam provide excellent energy return."

energy_return

carbon_technology

"The energy return from the Cielo X1 is exceptional, providing a propulsive running experience."

energy return

propulsion

high-stack midsole

"It is exceptionally lightweight, enhancing overall speed capabilities."

light

speed

responsive

"The lightweight construction helps runners feel nimble and swift on their feet."

weight

nimble

speed

"This shoe is designed for fast-paced road racing with a lightweight structure."

race shoe

lightweight

road racing

"The Hoka Cell X1 is lightweight, enhancing speed during runs."

lightweight

speed

tempo runs

"The shoe is lightweight, which contributes to a nimble feel during runs."

weight

nimble

performance

"The HOKA Cielo X1 is lightweight, beneficial for speed-focused runs."

lightweight

race

performance

"The Hoka Cielo X1 2.0 features a significantly reduced weight, enhancing speed during runs."

weight reduction

speed

fast runs

"The design and construction with modern elements contribute to its speed and performance."

carbon_fiber

design

speed

"The shoe is designed to be versatile for various runners, not just elite athletes."

versatility

carbon plate

all levels

"The aggressive rocker design enhances speed and promotes an efficient running style."

aggressive rocker

speed enhancement

"Hoka's signature rocker design enhances running efficiency over long distances."

rocker

efficient running

long distance

"The shoe has a pronounced rocker shape that enhances rebound during runs."

rebound

midfoot

"The Cielo X1 offers a significant rock-forward feel that enhances toe spring."

rock-forward

toe spring

energy return

"The rocker profile facilitates an efficient running stride, especially at speed."

rocker

efficiency

stride

"The aggressive rocker design of the Cielo X1 facilitates efficient toe-off while running."

rocker

efficiency

"The aggressive rocker geometry of the midsole enhances the running experience, providing a feeling of propulsion."

propulsive

aggressive

rocker

"The shoe features a rocker geometry that significantly enhances the running experience."

geometry

aggressive

rolling

"It has an aggressive rocker design that enhances the running stride and aids in turnover."

aggressive

turnover

stride

"Hoka C X1 has a more aggressive rocker profile than the New Balance SC Elite V4, leading to effective transitions in runs."

aggressive rocker

transitions

performance

"The shoe has a very aggressive rocker which contributes to a smooth running experience."

aggressive rocker

running experience

"The rocker technology effectively propels the runner forward, enhancing the running experience."

rocker technology

propulsion

"The shoe's aggressive forefoot rocker design enhances forward propulsion and overall running experience."

meta-rocker

forefoot

propulsion

"The shoe features a redesigned rocker geometry that enhances forefoot performance during runs."

rocker

forefoot

performance

"Testers praised the shoe’s ability to help maintain running speed, especially at faster paces."

speed

pace maintenance

"The Cielo X1 provides an invigorating sense of speed and energy return during runs."

energy return

marathon

tempo runs

"The shoe performed excellently during speed workouts, demonstrating its potential for racing scenarios."

performance

racing

speed workouts

"The Hoka Cielo X1 is recognized as Hoka's fastest carbon-plated model yet."

fast

carbon-plated

racing

"The shoe maintains a good level of comfort even during faster paces, which enhances performance on race day."

lively

energy return

comfortable at speed

"The Alphafly 3 performs well at faster paces, making it a suitable option for shorter races."

performance

short races

"The Hoka Cell X1 is considered more aggressive at faster paces."

faster paces

aggressiveness

"The shoe is designed for optimal speed and energy return, making it an excellent choice for race day."

race day

energy return

speed

"The shoe feels speedy underfoot, providing noticeable energy savings during runs."

energy return

marathon

tempo runs

"The shoe offers a very propulsive ride that enhances speed."

propulsive

speed

fun

"The overall ride dynamics of the shoe are excellent, offering a smooth running experience."

smooth ride

running dynamics

performance

"The Hoka Cielo X1 offers an incredible ride experience."

ride

smooth

surprising

"The foam and carbon plate offer excellent energy return for runners."

energy return

carbon plate

foam

"The shoe promotes energy-saving transitions which help during long runs."

transitions

energy-saving

efficiency

"The shoe provides a good energy return and a bouncy feel upon use, contributing to the running experience."

responsive

energy return

"The shoe provides excellent energy return and propulsion during runs."

energy return

propulsion

performance

"The shoe features a strong energy return that supports faster running."

energy return

midfoot land

"The early-stage Meta-Rocker promotes forward momentum effectively."

Meta-Rocker

momentum

forward motion

"The shoe offers a high energy return due to its advanced midsole construction."

midsole

carbon fiber

bounce

"The HOKA Cielo X1 offers a responsive and high-energy performance due to its carbon plate and foams."

carbon plate

propulsion

forward momentum

"The shoe maintains good energy return throughout the run."

energy return

consistent performance

"The design of the shoe promotes a forward rocking motion, aiding in energy return during runs."

performance

energy return

forward rocking

"The shoe features a high energy return, perfect for fast runs."

high energy return

fast running

aggressive feel

"The Cielo X1 features a highly responsive midsole that provides excellent energy return."

responds well

energy

performance

"The carbon-plated design provides a propulsive experience aimed at improving speed for competitive racing."

carbon-plated

racing speed

PB chasing

"The innovative winged carbon fiber plate contributes to a propulsive running experience."

propulsion

carbon fiber

responsive

"The CIELO X1 provides excellent propulsion that enhances running speed."

speed

cadence

dynamic ride

"The shoes demonstrate excellent propulsion, making it easier to maintain speed."

speed

tempo

efficiency

"The propulsion offered by the shoe is exceptional, providing a quick energy return that helps the runner move forward effectively."

energy return

fast

launch

"The carbon fiber plate contributes to a more efficient transition and enhances speed during runs."

responsive

driving forward

enhanced speed

"The shoe features a carbon fiber plate that propels the runner forward, improving efficiency."

carbon fiber

energy return

efficiency

"The shoe gives a strong feeling of propulsion, enhancing the running experience."

propelling forward

running posture

"The carbon fiber plate adds propulsion to the shoe's performance."

carbon fiber plate

energy return

performance

"The shoe's rocker geometry enhances the running experience by propelling the runner forward."

rocker geometry

efficient running

forward motion

"The shoe provides a fun running experience that can easily motivate you to lace up and hit the roads."

motivation

fun

enjoyable

"The rocker geometry and combination of midsole materials make it easy to get into a rhythm while running."

ease

rhythm

smooth transition

"The HOKA Cielo X1 features a responsive and bouncy PEBA midsole which enhances propulsion during runs."

PEBA

responsive

propulsion

"It offers a strong rocker shape promoting efficient transitions and fast running."

rocker

efficiency

transitions

"The Cielo X1 features an incredibly energetic ride, ideal for enthusiastic runners."

ride

energy

fun

"This shoe is designed specifically for marathon distances, making it marathon-ready."

marathon

race

performance

"The HOKA Cielo X1 offers a smooth and efficient ride suitable for marathon racing."

efficiency

snappiness

"The ride of the shoe is smooth and efficient, making it suitable for various paces and distances."

smooth ride

efficient

varied paces

"The shoe's design allows for a flexible foot strike, enhancing overall running performance."

flexibility

design

performance

"The Nike Alphafly 3 has a smoother and more fluid transition compared to the Hoka Yell X1."

smooth

fluid

"The SC Elite V4 has a smooth transition during runs, providing a comfortable experience during various paces."

smooth transition

comfort

various paces

"The shoe has a smooth heel-to-toe transition which aids fatigue management during longer runs."

heel-to-toe

flow

fatigue management

"The shoe's aggressive rocker design enhances the transition between paces, making it suitable for speed work."

rocker

transition

speedwork

"The shoe features a dual density midsole that enhances the smoothness of the ride and performance."

smooth

dual density

responsive

"The Hoka C LX1 offers an innovative and responsive midsole that enhances performance."

responsive

propulsion

bounce

"The shoe promotes good running form even with its aggressive rocker design."

good form

rocker

performance

"The traditional racing style of the SC Elite V4 is noted to be effective for marathon distances, enhancing the racing experience."

marathon

racing

performance

"The shoe provides a bouncy and fun ride that enhances the overall running experience."

fun ride

bouncy

performance

"The Hoka CL X1 offers a bouncy and energetic feel during runs."

energy

rocker

responsiveness

"The shoe maintains its bounce and performance over long distances without bottoming out."

long runs

springy

performance

"It performs well in various training settings, making it a good all-round shoe for both racing and casual runs."

all-around

training

racing

"The shoe feels lighter than expected given its features."

lightweight

tech

"The shoes are lightweight, which contributes positively to running performance."

speed

agility

"The shoe is notably light, enhancing running speed."

lightweight

speed enhancement

"The Cellow X1 is praised for its lightweight construction, making it easier for runners to maintain speed."

lightweight

speed

"The HOKA Cielo X 1 is lightweight, making it suitable for speed."

lightweight

speed

performance

"The shoe has a lightweight design that enhances overall running performance."

lightweight

speed

"The Cielo X1 2.0 is significantly lighter than its predecessor, improving speed and performance."

lightweight

performance

speed

"The shoe is described as fun and enjoyable to run in, encouraging use for tempo and progressive runs."

enjoyment

tempo runs

progressive runs

"The shoe offers a lively and enjoyable run experience."

fun

lively

running experience

"The performance of the Endorphin Pro 4 supports quick transitions during runs."

quickness

rocker

foams

"They offer excellent performance suitable for race day, making them ideal for competitive runners."

speed

efficiency

"The shoe facilitates a smooth ride, making it suitable for both training runs and race-day conditions."

smooth ride

training

race

"The outsole design incorporates a lightweight and unique approach, enhancing the shoe's performance."

lightweight

innovative design

stability

"The shoe's carbon fiber plate improves the running experience as it breaks in during use."

break-in

foot strike

carbon fiber

"The Hoka Cello X1 features a rockered geometry that propels the runner forward effectively."

rockered

forward propulsion

lively

"It was easy to maintain speed throughout the race."

speed

performance

grip

"The Alphafly 3 has an aggressive ride that enhances speed during runs."

aggressive ride

speed

"The shoe is designed for an aggressive running style, promoting a forward-leaning posture."

forward propulsion

toe-off

aggressive

"The carbon plate optimizes performance."

performance

optimization

"The design includes a unique carbon plate structure for improved performance."

carbon plate

performance boost

"The ride feels good at slower paces."

ride

comfort at speed

"The shoe is designed for high-speed races and can handle various race distances."

race_day

durable

speed

"The shoe has a very responsive foam that feels great when picking up pace."

responsive

speed

fun

"The shoe performs well on hilly terrain, providing good bounce and support while going up."

hill

performance

support

"The Rocket X2 is widely praised for its race day performance."

fast

competitive

response

"The aggressive rocker geometry allows for quicker toe-offs and smoother transitions, aiding in forward motion."

rocker

forward motion

smooth transitions

"The Hoka Super Shoes feature a state-of-the-art carbon fiber plate that enhances performance."

carbon fiber

performance

innovation

"They compare favorably to the Nike Alpha Fly, indicating high performance."

Nike Alpha Fly

high performance

comparison

"The shoe offers a notably smooth rebound and bounce with every foot strike, enhancing the running experience."

bounce

smooth

running experience

"The shoe performs exceptionally well during fast sprint efforts, especially on straight paths."

sprint performance

road runs

Cons

"While suitable for long distances, it may not be the best choice for short runs."

long-distance

short runs

"The shoe may be better suited for longer distances rather than shorter ones, potentially limiting versatility."

long distance

short distance limitation

"The shoe may not be ideal for longer distances."

long distance

performance

"The shoe is heavier than top-tier racing models, which may deter competitive runners."

heaviness

competitive

racing

"The shoe is perceived as clunky and heavy, which detracts from its racing performance."

clunky

heavy

"The overall weight of the shoe is considered excessive for a racing shoe, impacting speed."

heavy

racer

"Despite being ultralight, the shoe feels a tiny bit heavier compared to other super-shoes."

weight

heaviness

performance

comparison

"The shoe runs on the heavier side compared to similar models, which may impact performance."

weight

comparative

performance issue

"The shoe's weight is considered excessive for a race day option."

heavy

race day

"The shoe is heavier than typical racing shoes, which affects its competition suitability."

heaviness

racing

efficiency

"The shoe feels quite heavy compared to competitors."

weight

performance

racing

"The overall weight of the shoe is heavier than competitors like the Nike Alphafly 3, affecting performance."

heavy

performance

comparison

"The shoe is on the heavier side, which may not appeal to those looking for a lightweight option."

heavy

weight

performance

"The shoe feels heavy and bulky, which may deter elite runners."

heaviness

bulkiness

elite runners

"The shoe is considered heavy for a super shoe."

heavy

super shoe

performance

"The shoe's weight may not be suitable for runners looking for a lightweight option, especially in hilly terrains."

weight

hills

performance

"The shoe is considered heavy, making it potentially less competitive for performance."

heavy

performance

competitiveness

"The shoe's weight can be noticeable, especially uphill."

weight

hill performance

"Somewhat heavy on the foot despite good energy return."

weight

energy return

"The weight of the shoe is relatively high for a race day option."

heavy

race shoe

performance

"The shoes are heavier than expected for a super shoe."

heavy

super shoe

"The shoe is heavier than many competitors, which could affect performance."

heavy

performance

"The shoe feels bulky and heavy on foot."

heaviness

bulkiness

super shoe

"The shoe feels too heavy, which may impact performance during longer runs."

heavy

performance

marathon

"The Hoka Cell X1 is significantly heavier than the Alphafly 3."

heavy

racing shoe

weight difference

"The shoe's weight is heavier compared to competitors, which may affect performance."

heavier shoe

performance impact

"The weight of the shoe is heavier compared to other racing shoes."

heavy

comparison

"The Cloa X1 feels heavier on the foot than expected for a race day shoe."

heavy

race day

"The shoe's weight is heavier than expected for a super shoe, which may affect performance."

heaviness

super shoe

performance impact

"The shoe's weight compared to others may not be favored by all runners."

weight

comparison

"The weight of the shoe is considered too heavy for a racing model."

heavy

weight

"The shoe may not be ideal for elite runners looking for an ultra-light shoe for racing due to its weight."

elite runners

not suited

"The shoe feels awkward at slower paces, which may limit its versatility for different types of runs."

speed

versatility

"The shoe feels awkward at slower paces, affecting comfort and performance."

slow pace

awkward feel

performance

"The shoe does not feel fast or competitive for racing."

competitiveness

racing

softness

"The shoe is not suitable for running at speeds over 8 minutes per mile."

speed

limitation

"The performance characteristics of the Cell X1 may not cater to faster paces, implying it is less effective for speed work."

speed

performance

aggressive

"The shoe may push effort to the quads, which can be uncomfortable for some."

quads

effort

performance

"The shoes demand a higher level of input from the user, which may be challenging for less experienced runners."

beginner

performance

effort

"The higher drop of the shoe may take some adjustment for runners used to lower-drop shoes."

higher drop

adjustment

"The shoe can feel cumbersome at medium speeds."

medium pace

clunky

"The shoe's ride can be less appealing at slower speeds."

slow pace

reactivity

"The shoe is not suitable for medium to slower paced runs as it feels forced to go fast."

pace

performance

versatility

"The super shoe features may not benefit all runners equally, particularly those with slower paces."

performance_boost

variety_of_runners

super_shoes

"The shoe's bounciness may not suit those who prefer a softer midsole."

bounciness

midsole

softness

energy return

"The shoe's performance may not match that of top competitors in the super shoe category."

performance

super shoe

competition

"The shoe lacks the aggressive propulsion needed for top-tier racing."

propulsion

top-tier

racing

"The shoes may pose a risk of pace mismanagement due to their propulsion features."

propulsion

pace

effort

"The carbon plate is flexible, which detracts from the expected responsiveness in racing."

carbon plate

responsiveness

"The shoe does not perform well during easy runs due to its aggressive geometry."

not suitable

easy efforts

geometry

"It is not recommended for easy runs as it is designed specifically for racing."

race day

not for easy runs

specific use case

"The shoe doesn't provide a light feeling turnover for race day, which can be a disadvantage for some runners."

turnover

performance

race day

"The carbon fiber plate lacks aggressiveness and snap, disappointing for speedier runs."

carbon plate

speed

snappiness

"The SC Elite V4's performance isn't as pronounced as that of the C X1."

performance

speed

racing

"The shoe lacks an aggressive and fast feel, which is disappointing given its price point."

price

expectation

race day

"The drop does not feel aggressive enough compared to other options."

drop

performance

"The position of the 'sweet spot' feels awkward for faster paces."

positioning

awkwardness

pacing

"For its price, the shoe does not provide significant joy or benefits for an average runner."

value

performance

joy

"The continuous midsole design of the Nike may lead to a disconnect in transitions compared to the Hoka's design."

midsole

transition

"There is a noticeable transition bump when heel striking, which can disrupt the running flow."

heel strike

disruption

transition

"These shoes are not convenient for quick transitions in triathlons."

triathlon

transition time

inconvenience

"The Hoka CX1 does not feel as nimble and light as the Nike Alphafly 3 in shorter races."

nimble

short races

"The SC Elite V4 feels bulkier and less nimble than the C X1 when running."

performance

aggressiveness

bulk

"The shoe feels significantly chunkier compared to lighter racing flats."

chunky

heaviness

"Controlling the stride becomes harder when tired compared to lighter shoes."

tired

performance

effort

"The rocker profile is noted to not provide the explosive toe-off experienced in some competitor shoes."

toe-off

explosiveness

"This shoe requires a break-in period to optimize performance, which may be inconvenient."

break-in

performance

training

"The flexible plate reduces aggressive 4ft rocking."

aggressiveness

flexible plate

rocker

"The midsole of the Cellow X1 may feel overly bulky to some runners."

midsole

performance

bulk

"The Skywood X is deemed illegal for races due to its stack height exceeding regulations."

race

illegal

competition

"The Cloa X1 does not provide the desired vibe for race day performance."

lacks excitement

race day feel

"The shoe is not ideal for mile to 5K speed due to its cushioned design."

speed

"The shoe feels clunky during sharp turns due to its high stack height."

clunkiness

high stack

cornering

"The shoes require a specific midfoot striking gait to maximize benefits, limiting their versatility."

midfoot strike

gait

versatility

"The shoe's height may diminish its responsiveness on technical courses."

speed

technical

full distance

"The shoe's geometry may cause scuffing when running at slower cadences due to fatigue."

scuffing

cadence

"The shoes are optimized for long runs rather than sharp turns, which may limit performance in varied terrains."

limited

performance

"The shoe requires a strong forefoot push, which may not be suitable for slower-paced or tired conditions."

forefoot

performance

fit
True to size: True to size
Toebox width: Wider
Heel width: Average
Orthotic friendly: No

The most frequently mentioned issues with the shoe are problems with the lacing system, which is often described as difficult to secure and prone to coming undone, affecting the overall fit and comfort for users.

laces (32)

lacing (11)

entry (11)

width (8)

heel (6)

secure (4)

support (4)

narrow (4)

Pros

"The fit of the shoe is true to size and securely wraps around the foot."

true to size

roomy toe box

snug fit

"It fits true to size and provides ample room in the toe box."

true to size

toe box

fit

"Fit is true to size, contributing to the overall comfort and performance of the shoe."

fit

comfortable

"The fit of the shoe is precise and true to size, accommodating the user's foot well."

true_to_size

comfort

fit

"The fit of the shoe can be adjusted, with a snug upper that provides a secure feel."

fit

sockfit

upper

"The fit of the shoe is secure and comfortable, ensuring a good hold while running."

fits well

heel hold

comfortable

"The innovative lacing system, while requiring effort to adjust, ultimately offers a secure fit contributing to overall comfort."

snug

lacing

adjustable

"The upgraded lacing system provides a more secure fit, boosting confidence during high-speed efforts."

lacing system

heel counter

responsive fit

"The Cielo X1 offers an accommodating fit for a variety of foot types."

fit

wide toes

"The shoe provides a comfortable fit that accommodates wider feet, making it user-friendly for various runners."

toe box

fit

pressure points

"The Cielo X1 has a snug ankle collar that provides support without sacrificing comfort."

ankle support

snug fit

"The HOKA Cielo X1 provides serious support once the laces are properly tightened."

lace difficulty

triathlon adaptation

"The Active Foot Frame technology enhances the fit and foot stability in the shoe."

foot stability

fit

support

"The upper construction is supportive and wraps around the foot nicely, providing a secure fit."

supportive

secure fit

upper material

"The upper is accommodating, providing comfort for runners with wide feet."

accommodating

fit

wide feet

"The Hoka Cielo X1 caters well to wide footers, providing ample space in the forefoot, midfoot, and heel areas."

wide fit

comfort

fit

"The fit is designed to be comfortable and accommodating, especially for wider feet."

wide fit

comfort

"The shoe provides ample volume, making it suitable for runners with wider feet."

wide feet

ample volume

"The shoe provides good width in the toe box, accommodating runners with wider feet."

fit

toe box

width

"The upper of the shoe is very supportive and fits snugly around the instep."

ribbed knit

high instep

"The snug, foot-hugging fit of the upper enhances the overall feel and performance of the shoe."

foot-hugging

asymmetrical tongue

locking effect

"The shoe features a snug fit that locks the foot securely in place during runs."

secure

fit

upper

snug

"The shoes are designed with a snug fit that enhances comfort once laced."

snug fit

comfort

lacing

"The roomy toebox design contributes to overall comfort, allowing for a better fit during longer runs."

roomy

stable fit

"Many testers found the fit of the shoe to be perfect, particularly those with narrow feet."

fit

narrow feet

comfort

"The shoes have a unique lace system that keeps them securely in place during runs, reducing the risk of needing adjustments mid-run."

secure

laces

convenience

"The Cielo-X1 allows for a smoother transition and helps to reduce lace bite."

lace

fit

comfort

"The shoe maintains a signature Hoka rockered design, promoting a smooth forward motion when running."

rocker

smooth

forward

"The fit is snug and performance-oriented, catering well to runners who like a close fit."

snug

fit

comfort

"Includes features like a semi-gusseted tongue which improves the overall snugness without being overly restrictive."

gussset

tongue

snug

"The Prime X2 Strong's tongue design prevents bunching and pressure on the top of the foot during runs."

tongue design

comfort

running pressure

"The stretchy tongue provides a sock-like comfort which enhances the fit."

stretchy tongue

sock-like fit

"The shoe fits true-to-size with a snug midfoot fit, suitable for racing."

fit

snug

racing

"The overall construction of the shoe integrates well with the midsole sidewalls to enhance performance."

construction

integration

performance

"The CIELO X1 has a well-fitted upper design that adds to the overall experience."

fitted

design

aesthetic

"The upper construction is designed for durability and structured support, improving comfort during runs."

structured

durable

comfort

"The engineered mesh upper provides a much better fit, enhancing comfort and lockdown."

fit

comfort

mesh

"The HOKA Cielo X1 offers an excellent heel and midfoot lockdown when laced tightly, ensuring a secure fit during runs."

secure fit

laces

heel lockdown

"Lockdown in the shoe is excellent, creating a secure fit during runs."

secure fit

great lockdown

"The shoe provides a good lock down with its lacing system."

fit

laces

secure

"The shoe offers a comfortable fit with a structured upper that provides moderate lockdown."

upper

structured

fit

"The shoe provides an incredible lockdown experience, enhancing performance during runs."

lockdown

fit

performance

"The fit of the shoe is secure and comfortable, providing a good lockdown for the foot during runs."

secure fit

natural lockdown

comfort

"The SC Elite V4 features an effective fit system that provides a more secure lockdown for the midfoot."

secure

fit system

"The shoe has a well-designed upper that provides a secure fit without being too constrictive."

fit

upper

secure

"The fit provided by the upper material is secure and stable, enhancing the lockdown."

secure

stable

connected

"The spacious toe box accommodates foot swelling, making it suitable for long-distance running."

toe box

foot swelling

long distance

"The upper fit is true to size and offers ample room for the toes, enhancing comfort during runs."

true to size

comfort

spacious

"The toe box is spacious, offering more room for the feet, especially important during long runs."

spacious

comfort

long run

"Both shoes have a decent toe box width, minimizing irritation."

toe box

irritation

"The fit of the shoe is comfortable and accommodating, particularly for runners with wider feet."

wide fit

comfort

toe splay

"The fit of both shoes, including toe box and heel structure, is comfortable for long runs."

fit

comfort

"The shoe's fit is true to size and offers more room compared to other super shoes, enhancing overall comfort."

true to size

comfort

accommodating

"The shoe has a roomy toebox and provides a stable fit, beneficial for different foot shapes."

toebox

stable fit

wide fit

"The shoe is designed to cater to a wide range of runners, particularly those with midfoot striking patterns."

midfoot striking

wide range

assistance

"The SC Elite V4 provides a comfortable run with ample toe space, allowing for longer distances without discomfort."

toe box

comfort

long runs

"The fit of both shoes was generally good, with a roomy toe box that seems accommodating for longer runs."

fit

roomy

toe box

"The shoe fits true to size, ensuring a reliable fit for runners."

true to size

reliable fit

"The shoe offers a secure fit thanks to interesting lacing technology that locks down well."

secure

lockdown

fit

"The lacing system provides a secure fit once adjusted correctly."

secure lacing

adjustable fit

"The traditional lacing system adds to the secure fit of the shoes."

traditional lacing

secure fit

"The flat laces provide a secure fit against the foot."

flat profile

secure fit

no slip

"The laces are designed to stay tied securely during runs."

secure

no untie

"The laces are grippy and allow for a secure lockdown, enhancing the overall fit of the shoe."

secure fit

lockdown

grippy

"The laces provide consistent pressure across the foot and help with fit stability."

fit

laces

stability

"The traditional lacing system of the Cellow X1 is preferred by the reviewer over the Skywood X, claiming it offers better usability."

lacing

reviewer preference

"The updated laces are an improvement, allowing for a solid and secure tying."

laces

fit

security

"The tongue is fully gusseted, enhancing security."

gusseted

secure

"The gusseted tongue design ensures that it stays in place during runs, contributing to the shoe's comfort and fit."

gusseted_tongue

secure_fit

comfort

"Both shoes have a good fit and hold well around the midfoot and heel."

midfoot

heel

width

"The fit is initially challenging, but this is a common trait among race shoes, and does not affect performance once worn."

ease of entry

"The shoe provides a secure fit with a well-structured upper that offers a great lockdown without irritation."

secure fit

upper structure

lockdown

"The upper has customizable fit options with additional eyelets."

fit

customizable

upper

"The knit upper with a gusseted tongue enhances fit customization."

knit upper

fit

gusseted tongue

"The shoe provides a roomier fit that accommodates different foot shapes."

fit

roomy

comfort

"The shoe had a decent fit for the wearer."

fit

upper

"The Hoka C X1 fits true to size, providing ample room for the toes without being overly wide."

true to size

toe room

"The Alphafly 3 provides a good fit but may require sizing up due to its shorter length."

sizing

fit issue

"The Prime X2 Strong has a well-designed heel tab that aids in putting the shoe on easily."

heel tab

fit

easy to wear

"The lacing system of the CX1 reduces pressure on the top of the foot due to its flat profile."

lacing system

comfort

top pressure

"The shoe provides a good fit around the toes, allowing ample room without rubbing."

fit

toe room

"The Hoka CL X1 has an excellent fit with good volume in the toe box."

fit

volume

comfort

"The shoes feature a unique lacing system that adapts well once set up."

fit

lacing

"It is flexible, making it a good option for runners with wider feet."

flexibility

width

"The fit of the Hoka Rocket X2 is noted to be better for the reviewer, indicating good individual fit characteristics."

fit

personal preference

"The Hoka Cell X1 is recommended for runners with a higher volume foot, indicating good adaptability in fit."

fit

adaptability

"The heel counter of the Skywood X is innovative, aiding in easy on-and-off wear while providing excellent structure."

heel design

ease of use

"The heel drop accommodates heel strikers well, enhancing push-off during runs."

heel striker

push-off

fit

"The asymmetrical gusseted tongue design contributes to a snug and comfortable fit."

gusseted tongue

snug fit

"Adequate heel padding keeps the heel firmly in place."

heel padding

lockdown

fit

"The attached tongue prevents movement and adds to the overall fit of the shoe."

attached tongue

fit stability

secure fit

"The Cielo X1 shoes work well for midfoot strikers, enhancing stride and acceleration."

midfoot strike

acceleration

"The Cielo X1 provides a comfortable fit that remains true to size compared to other HOKA models."

fit

HOKA range

length

width

"The innovative design of the collar provides excellent heel lock without compromising comfort."

heel lock

comfort

design

"The Hoka Cielo X1 2.0's engineered jacquard mesh upper offers a snug and stable fit while ensuring breathability during runs."

jacquard mesh

breathability

snug fit

Cons

"The lacing system does not provide a secure fit."

lacing

tightness

"The lacing system of the Hoka C X1 is not optimal, requiring extra effort to achieve a good lockdown."

lacing

lockdown

effort

"The lockdown of the shoe is not entirely secure, failing to provide confidence in performance."

fit

lockdown

performance

"The shoe feels challenging to set up for the best lockdown due to its lacing system."

setup

lockdown

user experience

"The laces are awkward to use and require extra effort to secure properly."

awkward

tightening

design

"The laces have potential reliability issues, as one instance resulted in coming undone."

reliability

lace issues

"The design of the laces is not preferred compared to traditional lace types."

preference

traditional

lace design

"The lacing system is awkward, making it difficult to secure the shoe appropriately."

awkward

laces

"The laces do not stay tied well, which can be distracting during runs."

laces

unstable

"The thin laces are ineffective and do not stay tied well during runs."

laces

staying tied

"The laces are made from a weird and stiff material that may affect usability."

difficult to tie

strange material

shoe design

"The laces are stiff and difficult to adjust quickly, which is problematic for triathletes."

stiff

difficult to adjust

triathlon

"The laces have issues with staying tied and adjusting tension properly."

laces

adjustability

fit issue

"The laces are difficult to manipulate and don't provide a secure fit."

tightness

ease of use

fit

"The laces frequently come undone during runs."

laces

stability

comfort

"The laces are described as the worst ever tested by the reviewer, being rigid and prone to untying."

laces

inconvenience

untying

"The laces are mentioned as being a bit different and might not provide an optimal fit for everyone."

laces

fit

adjustability

"The laces are not satisfactory and were criticized in the previous review."

laces

fit

"The laces may require extra attention to prevent them from coming untied."

untied laces

fit

attention

"The laces do not hold their tie well."

laces

tie

"The laces are described as cheap, rigid, and prone to unlacing, impacting the overall experience."

laces

cheap

unlacing

"The laces are thin and do not stay tied effectively."

laces

durability

fit issue

"The laces are described as rigid and difficult to manipulate, which can detract from the overall experience."

lacing

rigid

"The shoe may not transition quickly for triathletes due to the lace system."

triathlete

lace system

transition

"The laces are of poor quality and affect overall fit."

laces

fit

quality

"The laces on the CLX1 are flat, stiff, and difficult to adjust."

lace issue

adjustment

flat

"The laces of the Hoka Cellow X1 do not stay tied easily."

laces

fit

design

"The laces themselves lack personality and feel cheap for a high-priced shoe."

lack of character

cheap feel

"The laces are thin and make it hard to achieve a good lockdown."

thin laces

lockdown issue

"The laces tend to come undone during runs, which raises concerns about their reliability."

laces

reliability

fit

"The shoelaces are difficult to tie and do not stay secure during runs."

shoelaces

knot

security

"The laces are stiff and difficult to adjust quickly, making them inconvenient for triathletes."

triathlon

adjustability

stiffness

"Laces are prone to untie easily during use."

laces

untied

fit adjustment

"Difficult to adjust the tension of the laces to achieve a secure fit."

fit adjustment

tension

laces

"The laces on the Cielo X1 are problematic and frequently come undone."

laces

fit issue

inconvenience

"The laces may not stay tied securely during runs."

laces

staying secure

"The upper material is stiff, contributing to a less than ideal fit."

stiff

upper

"The upper may feel too substantial for some runners, leading to a potentially clunky feel."

upper

bulk

clunkiness

"While sturdy, the upper's fit can also be problematic for some users."

upper material

fit

adjustment

"The fit might feel restrictive for runners with wider feet due to the sockfit upper."

sockfit

fit

"The snug ankle collar makes it difficult to put the shoes on."

ankle

snug

difficulty

"The shoe's entry point can be difficult, making it tricky to wear at first."

entry

difficulty

tricky

"Getting the shoe on and off is a challenging process due to design flaws."

pull tab

fit

"The absence of a heel tab can make it difficult to put the shoes on easily."

heel tab

fit

ease of use

"Putting the shoe on can be quite difficult due to its design."

difficulty

entry

design

"The upper of the shoe is difficult to fit into, making the initial experience frustrating."

fit

upper

"The shoe is difficult to put on due to a stiff upper."

stiff upper

difficult entry

racing shoe

"The shoe is cumbersome to put on."

ease

frustration

"The fit of the Cloa X1 makes it difficult to put on."

struggle

tight

"The shoe may be wobbly when putting it on due to its design."

wobbliness

design

"Putting the shoes on can be a challenge due to the lacing system."

difficulty

time-consuming

"The fit may not be ideal for all foot shapes despite being accommodating for wide feet."

wide feet

fit

accommodating

"The material of the upper may not be accommodating for runners with wider feet due to its thickness and stiffness."

thick material

stiffness

wide feet

"The shoe may compress wider feet, which could be uncomfortable for some users."

compression

wide feet

fit issues

"The shoe may not accommodate wider feet comfortably."

narrow

fit

foot

shape

"Once fitted, the shoe feels wide, requiring tight lacing that can be uncomfortable."

wide

lacing

"The Alphafly 3's midfoot is noticeably narrow."

narrow

midfoot

fit issue

"The shoe feels narrow in the midfoot and heel, making it potentially uncomfortable for wider feet."

narrow

width concern

"The upper material might not accommodate individuals with wide feet due to its thickness and stiffness."

wide feet

upper material

"The tongue of the shoe has a loose construction that does not spring back, leading to a folded appearance during use."

tongue

design

construction

"The tongue material is overly stretchy which affects fit."

tongue

stretch

fit

"The tongue design of the SC Elite V4 is considered subpar."

tongue

design

comfort

"The attached tongue may rub against the ankle."

attached tongue

ankle rub

"The shoes lack a heel tab, making it difficult to put them on without straining your fingers."

heel tab

difficulty

fit

"The heel counter can be rigid and may require care when putting the shoe on."

heel counter

rigidity

putting on shoe

"The heel cup design leads to excessive heel movement, which can cause irritation during slow runs."

heel movement

irritation

"The heel design of the SC Elite V4 can lead to issues with heel slip."

fit

heel slip

looseness

"There is no option for heel lock lacing, which may cause blisters."

heel lock

blisters

fit issue

"The heel cup lacks padding, risking blisters."

heel cup

padding

blisters

"The lack of upper lacing holes prevents effective heel locking, which can lead to slipping."

heel lock

fit issue

slip

"There is a learning curve associated with the Cielo X1 that requires time and preparation before full use."

training

injury_risk

adaptation

"The fit may be inaccurate due to unisex sizing, leading to a larger feel."

unisex sizing

fit

run feel

"The fit may be a hit or miss depending on the individual's foot shape."

personal fit

sizing issues

individual shape

"Unisex sizing may lead to confusion regarding fit, especially for women used to specific sizing."

unisex

fit

sizing issues

"The fit may be too snug for runners with wider feet."

snug fit

wide feet

narrow

"The fit is narrow and may not be accommodating for all foot types."

fit

narrow

"The Hoka C X1 has a narrower fit which might be uncomfortable for wider feet."

narrow fit

wide feet

squeeze

"The shoe may feel narrow for runners, especially after long distances."

narrow

long distance

tight

"The shoe is difficult to put on due to the design and lack of a pull tab."

putting on

design

fit

"The pressure on the toes can be uncomfortable during longer runs, especially for those with wider feet."

toe pressure

comfort

long runs

"The shoe lacks sufficient breathability and can become too warm during runs."

warmth

breathability

upper material

"The lacing system can be difficult to tighten properly, requiring double knotting to prevent loosening."

lacing difficulty

tightening

double knotting

"The lacing system requires considerable effort to put on the shoes."

difficult

tight fit

"The flat laces do not glide easily through the eyelets, making adjustment cumbersome."

friction

design issue

"The laces have a tendency to come undone during runs."

lace issues

confidence

"The lacing system feels plasticky, taking time to get used to."

plasticky

lacing

user experience

"The lacing system on the Hoka C X1 has been poorly received by some."

lacing system

negative feedback

"The shoes are difficult to put on initially due to the lacing system."

lacing system

difficulty

fit

"The laces are difficult to tie and do not stay tied well, which is problematic for racing."

difficult lacing

unstable

hard to tie

"The different lacing system complicates getting the foot in and adjusting the fit."

lacing system

fit

adjustment

"There are no extra eyelets for additional lacing adjustments, which may limit customization of fit."

customization

lacing

fit adjustments

"The lacing system is difficult to adjust and does not glide smoothly."

adjustment

difficult

practicality

"The shoe may not be suitable for runners who prefer a more traditional feeling shoe."

rockered

traditional feel

shoe preference

"The upper material of the HOKA Cielo X1 is too rigid and thick, making it uncomfortable for some runners."

rigidity

comfort

upper

"The upper material might be thicker than usual, contributing to weight."

thickness

fit

weight

"The Hoka CX1 feels heavier than expected for a racing shoe."

heavy

racing shoe

weight

"The lace adjustment is challenging due to the shoe's design."

laces

design

adjustability

"The shoe lacks a wide toe box, potentially causing discomfort for runners with wider feet."

wide foot

discomfort

toe box

"There's too much volume in the forefoot area, which may require sizing adjustments for a better fit."

forefoot

volume

sizing

"The Hoka Rocket X2 is preferred for its fit, suggesting potential issues with the fit of the Cell X1 for some runners."

fit

volume

preference

"The midfoot arch fit may cause discomfort during runs."

fit

discomfort

"Not suitable for runners who heavily heel-strike due to a risk of awkward foot placement."

heel strike

fit

"The upper is too structured and doesn't conform well to the foot."

upper

fit

narrow foot

lace adjustment

"The knit upper of the Hoka Cellow X1 may not conform well for those with narrow feet."

upper

fit

narrow foot

"The SC Elite V4 lacks internal heel padding, leading to fit issues around the heel."

fit

heel padding

comfort

"The shoe runs slightly small, needing potential size adjustments for longer runs."

sizing

fit

adjustment

"The shoe may fit a bit loose, leading to a less secure feel during runs."

loose

snug fit

"The shoes are difficult to put on initially."

onboarding

fit

struggle

"The tongue design is problematic and can bunch up."

tongue

fit

design

"The lacing system design creates excessive friction, making it hard to adjust properly."

friction

eyelets

lockdown

"The laces of the shoe are stiff and difficult to manage during use."

laces

stiffness

difficulty

"Some runners may feel loose in the heel area due to its design."

looseness

design

"The shoelaces are poorly designed and difficult to work with."

shoelaces

lockdown

difficulty

"The upper's fit can be too roomy for those who prefer snug racing shoes."

snug fit

race fit

size adjustment

"The Alphafly 3 may be too short in length."

size

bruise

length issue

"There's a bit of bunching around the eyelets which affects the snugness of the fit."

bunching

eyelets

fit issue

"The laces are of poor quality and not suitable for the shoe."

quality

annoyance

"There is an excessive amount of room in the toe box for narrow feet."

toe box

narrow fit

excess fabric

"The shoe's higher stack height might not be suitable for everyone, particularly those who don't adapt well to taller shoes."

stack height

drop

adaptability

"The size of the Cellow X1 appears larger than other running shoe brands, which may not appeal to all runners."

size

appearance

aesthetics

"The shoe's upper lacks elasticity, which might not be ideal for a race day shoe."

upper

fit

race day

"The laces tend to come undone during runs, requiring a double knot to secure them."

laces

undone

distraction

"The shoe is not suitable for heel strikers, which could limit its usability for some runners."

heel striker

fit

stability
Stability level: Average

The most common issues with the shoe's stability include concerns about its design leading to instability at slower speeds and during turns, which were mentioned frequently.

rocker (3)

design (3)

plate (3)

neutral (3)

base (3)

heel (3)

lateral (3)

overall (2)

Pros

"It offers stability through its wide footprint and design features."

stability

wide footprint

design

"The shoe has a stable ride that improves confidence during runs."

stable

confidence

"This shoe provides a stable feel, enhancing security during runs."

stability

balance

security

"The shoe's heel counter effectively locks the rearfoot in place, minimizing slippage."

slippage

rearfoot stability

"The heel counter is firm yet low, ensuring that the foot remains locked in place during runs."

stability

heel counter

locked in

"The shoe features a pronounced rocker that effectively enhances forward motion."

forward propulsion

smooth transition

"The exaggerated rocker shape effectively propels the runner forward."

propulsion

rocker design

"The shoe's design includes a pronounced heel bevel and long rocker, aiding in smooth transitions during runs."

heel bevel

long rocker

smooth transitions

"The aggressive rocker geometry invigorates each stride."

rocker

invigorating

stability

"The Hoka Rocket X2 is described as more rockered, which helps with smoother transitions from midfoot to forefoot during running."

rocker

transitions

midfoot

"The shoe's design allows for a smooth stride due to its pronounced rocker."

rocker design

smooth stride

rolling effect

"The winged carbon fiber plate enhances the stability and performance of the shoe during runs."

winged design

stability

performance

"The shoe's midsole includes a full-length carbon fiber plate, enhancing propulsion and stability."

stability

rigidity

propulsion

"The carbon-fiber plate adds stability to the shoe, which is particularly useful for those needing extra support."

carbon plate

stability

support

"The cushioning offers support that benefits runners with less strength towards the end of a marathon."

support

marathon

wider base

"Offers decent support on cambered roads despite being classified as a neutral shoe."

neutral

camber support

"The shoe performed well in terms of stability and support during the race."

stability

support

design

"The shoe's upper provides good support."

upper support

structure

"The midsole's design allows for great stability and support."

stability

support

midsole design

"The winged carbon fiber plate improves stability while aiding forward propulsion."

carbon plate

forward propulsion

shoe stability

"The wide forefoot provides a comfortable landing zone for runners during their strides."

wide forefoot

comfort

stability

"The Hoka Cielo X1 has a stable design due to large sidewalls and a wider base."

stability

design

width

"The shoe's weight distribution enhances stability during runs, particularly for overpronators."

overpronation

footstrike

stability

"The CX1 is perceived to be more stable due to its lower heel-to-toe drop and winged carbon plate."

stability

design

midsole

"The shoe offers extra stability due to its winged design."

stability

winged

race day

"Offers lateral guidance due to its design elements which aid in stability."

lateral guidance

design

support

"The shoe has a winged carbon plate that enhances side to side stability during runs."

carbon

stability

"The inclusion of a carbon fiber plate adds to the stability and responsiveness of the shoe."

carbon fiber

stability wings

responsiveness

"The shoe has a well-engineered carbon plate that enhances stability during runs."

carbon plate

stability

engineering

"The shoe offers good stability with its neutral support, accommodating various foot types without added support."

stable

neutral

"The shoes provide excellent stability, even with their substantial stack height."

stability

support

control

"The shoe offers stability despite being categorized as neutral, which is beneficial during diverse runs."

stability

neutral

versatility

"The shoe's geometry helps to align the gait cycle, promoting a controlled footstrike that's beneficial for runners."

gait cycle

footstrike

pronation control

"The shoe offers smooth transitions while running, enhancing the overall experience."

smooth

stable

"The shoe exhibits a 'tippy toe' feeling which aids in quick transitions during runs."

meta rocker

quick transitions

"The shoe features a wide base that enhances stability compared to other marathon racers."

wide base

enhanced stability

"The Alphafly 3's wider base contributes to improved stability when landing."

wider base

stability

"The shoe is designed to be stable even on varied surfaces, making it suitable for road racing."

stability

wide_base

road_racing

"It has a unique geometry that supports a midfoot strike and provides a targeted landing."

midfoot strike

smooth transition

targeted landing

"The heel counter provides strong support and lockdown."

support

lockdown

"The dual-density foam structure enhances stability during runs."

dual density

stability

"It performs well on various terrains, providing a stable feel during different types of runs (gravel, road, trails)."

gravel

road

trails

"The shoe features a unique winged carbon fiber plate that enhances propulsion and stability during runs."

carbon fiber plate

stability

propulsion

"The carbon plate enhances propulsion while maintaining stability."

carbon plate

stability

"The shoe’s wide platform enhances stability during runs."

wide platform

stability

"The aggressive rocker geometry aids in effortless running."

rocker

effortless_running

"The wide footprint enhances stability during runs."

wide_footprint

stable

"The Hoka Rocket X2 has a 5 mm drop which provides a favorable transition for runners during their gait cycle."

drop

transition

gait cycle

"The winged plate provides a sense of stability while running at speed."

winged plate

stability

"The engineered knit upper ensures a secure but comfortable fit, contributing to the overall stability."

engineered knit

secure fit

stability

"The upper provides good structure and stability for race-day performance."

structure

stability

Cons

"The shoe design is unstable, particularly at slower speeds."

instability

speed

"The shoe's design may lead to instability due to its unique cutout placements, which could confuse users regarding their purpose."

instability

cutouts

"The SC Elite V4 may not provide adequate stability compared to the Cellow X1."

stability

midsole

plate

"The shoe's aggressive rocker makes it difficult to navigate uneven terrain safely."

rocker

terrain

stability

"The shoe's aggressive rocker design may not feel suitable for all runners."

rocker

foot strike

stability

"The aggressive rocker doesn't initiate cleanly when standing neutrally, impacting performance for certain runners."

aggressive rocker

performance

neutral stance

"The shoe may feel unstable at times, especially for runners with a different foot strike pattern."

unstable

lateral sway

sensitivity to form

"The shoe's cutouts in the sole may reduce side-to-side stability during track work."

cutouts

stability

track issue

"There are some stability issues which may affect runners needing more support."

stability

support

neutral

"The shoe lacks sufficient ground connection, making it feel unstable for some runners."

ground connection

stability

"The lateral cutout in the midfoot can lead to instability on cambered roads and during sharp turns."

instability

lateral cutout

cambered roads

"Potential for quick inversion moments due to midfoot cutout may concern those with lateral stability needs."

ankle sprains

inversion moments

stability concerns

"The Hoka Cell X1 may feel unstable for those with lateral stability issues."

instability

ankle sprains

lateral stability

"The midsole compresses significantly upon landing, making the shoe feel lower than its stated drop."

drop

compression

midsole

"The shoe's construction allows for a pronounced drop, which might feel higher for sensitive runners."

higher drop

measurement

"The lateral mid foot cutout design might lead to stability concerns for some runners with ankle issues."

stability

ankle issues

design

"The Hoka's heel design does not feel as well-executed as Nike's."

heel design

stability

"Concerns about stability in the heel area during fatigue are raised for longer runs."

stability

fatigue

marathon

"The heel counter lacks adequate support and feels flimsy."

heel counter

support

flimsy

"The upper lacks proper lockdown, resulting in movement inside the shoe, affecting stability."

movement

lockdown

stability

"There's a risk of instability when turning due to the design."

stability

turning risk

"The lateral cutout can compromise stability during turns on uneven surfaces."

cutout

stability

turns

"Surface camber can cause issues with ankle stability due to shoe design."

camber

ankle

turns

"Neither shoe provides significant stability elements."

neutral

no stability

control

"There may be concerns regarding stability during fatigue."

stability

performance

fatigue

"There are trade-offs in stability when fatigue sets in."

stability

performance

"The shoe is confusing when measuring its stack height due to the considerable bevel in the heel."

stack height

bevel

measurement

rocker

"There's a lack of flexibility due to the design, which may not cater to all user preferences."

design

flexibility

instability

"The shoe seems aggressive which may take time to get used to."

aggression

adjustment

"The shoe feels wobbly and unstable due to its height and design."

wobbly

unstable

height

"Cornering feels unstable and tippy due to the stack height of the foam."

tippy

cornering instability

"While designed for stability, the shoe's propulsion may not feel stable enough for some runners."

stability

propulsion

design

"The Hoka Cell X1 may require more effort during transitions due to its lower rockered design."

rocker

transition

effort

"The shoe may feel less smooth during transitions, especially when fatigue sets in."

fatigue

transition issue

smoothness

"The heel counter is too flexible and lacks structure, which can affect lockdown."

heel counter

flexibility

lockdown

"The shoe feels unstable, especially if foot placement is not perfect during runs."

foot placement

lateral sway

"The shoe feels unstable at slower running paces and during walking, which may compromise comfort for some users."

stability

slow pace

"Cut outs in the sole reduce side-to-side stability for track work."

track work

stability

cutouts

"Narrower midfoot and heel footprint leads to increased instability for midfoot and heel strikers."

narrower

instability

heel strikers

"The shoe's narrow base and aggressive design may feel insecure during longer runs or on uneven surfaces."

narrow base

uneven surfaces

long runs

"There is a perceived lack of midfoot and arch support, which may lead to discomfort for some runners."

midfoot

arch support

stability

"Runners who rely on the arch support might feel discomfort at slow paces or longer distances due to the midsole changes."

arch support

stability

grip

The main concerns about the shoe's grip are that it may not perform well on slippery surfaces and could lack confidence in wet conditions, which were mentioned frequently.

outsole (4)

coverage (3)

traction (2)

rubber coverage (2)

wet (2)

versatile (1)

durability (1)

performance (1)

Pros

"The shoe has excellent grip and traction on various surfaces, improving safety during runs."

grip

traction

stability

"The outsole's design provides excellent grip on various surfaces, enhancing safety."

grip

traction

cornering

"The shoe delivers good traction on road surfaces, making it versatile for different running environments."

road surfaces

urban

country roads

"The shoe offers good traction on various surfaces, contributing to overall performance."

traction

outsole

performance

"The shoe offers solid traction, aiding in stability and confidence while navigating different terrains."

traction

grip

"The rubber outsole provides excellent grip, even in wet conditions, which contributes to the overall performance."

rubber outsole

wet conditions

"The shoes perform well in various conditions, including wet and dry, ensuring consistent traction."

solid

wet

dry

"The outsole provides excellent grip, enhancing performance on various surfaces during runs."

rubber

durability

performance

"The shoe provides excellent traction on various surfaces, ensuring confidence while running."

confidence

traction

versatile surfaces

"The traction performance of the Hoka C LX1 is slightly better than the SC Elite V4, making it versatile across different terrains."

traction

versatility

"There is a good amount of grip and traction, suitable for both dry and wet conditions."

grip

traction

wet_conditions

"The traction on the outsole is effective for various terrains, including wet conditions."

traction

outsole

"The outsole provides excellent grip, enhancing performance on different surfaces."

outsole

grip

traction

"The outsole design offers durable traction, even in wet conditions, enhancing confidence while running."

rubber outsole

wet conditions

durability

"The shoes exhibit solid grip and traction, suitable for various conditions."

wet conditions

dry conditions

traction

"The sticky rubber outsole provides reliable grip on slick surfaces, enhancing performance on various terrains."

outsole

traction

wet conditions

"The shoe maintains solid grip and traction in wet conditions, providing confidence during runs."

wet weather

traction

confidence

"The shoe offers good grip, making it reliable on various surfaces, including wet conditions."

grip

wet conditions

reliable

"The blown rubber outsole provides good grip and durability for varied terrains."

good grip

durability

blown rubber

"The review mentions good grip due to the rubber used in the outsole."

traction

durability

"The grip on the outsole was a highlight during the race."

grip

stability

outdoor

"The outsole has excellent rubber coverage providing a reliable grip during runs."

outsole

grip

durability

"The shoe has a significant amount of rubber coverage on the outsole, contributing to grip and durability."

traction

outsole durability

grip

"The shoe can handle a variety of conditions, providing versatility for runners."

variety

conditions

bouncy

"The outsole features ample rubber coverage which offers good grip on various surfaces."

rubber coverage

grip

"The outsole provides reliable grip and coverage for a range of surfaces, including wet conditions."

good coverage

wet conditions

"The grip on the outsole of the Hoka CL X1 provides good traction despite some cutouts."

traction

rubber

outsole

"The shoe has a durable outsole that provides grip without wearing down quickly."

grip

outsole

durability

"The CX1 performs well in terms of grip even in varied conditions, making it reliable for running."

high grip

performance

varied conditions

Cons

"The minimalist outsole design may not provide enough grip on slippery surfaces."

minimalist

outsole

traction

grip

"The grip is adequate in most conditions but lacks confidence in damp settings, especially during toe-off."

grip

damp

toe-off

"The traction might be inadequate in wet or greasy conditions, causing concerns for some runners."

wet

anxiety

traction

"Wet weather performance has not been tested, which leaves uncertainty about grip."

wet weather

grip

performance

"Potential for picking up stones due to the cutaway in the midsole, which could be a concern on certain terrains."

gravel

cutaway

other

The most frequently mentioned issues with the shoe are its high price, which is considered excessive by many users, and the laces, which are often described as poorly designed and prone to coming undone.

price (13)

weight (12)

laces (10)

pricing (4)

aesthetics (3)

heaviness (3)

design (2)

cost (2)

Pros

"The shoe features a lightweight and minimal design, enhancing agility."

lightweight

minimal

agility

"Weight of the Hoka CL X1 is not a detriment to its performance."

performance

feel

fast

"The shoes are slightly heavier than some rivals, but the added comfort makes up for it."

weight

comfort

"Reflective elements enhance visibility during low-light runs, adding a safety feature."

reflective

safety

visibility

"The shoe has an innovative design that stands out visually, making it a stylish option."

style

color

unique appearance

"The colorful design of the shoe is visually appealing and stands out."

colorful

visual appeal

"The overall design aesthetics of the shoe are appealing and visually attractive."

aesthetics

colorway

texture

"The shoe has a striking and attractive design."

aesthetic

color

"The design of the shoe is visually appealing, even though the colorway may not be ideal for everyone."

aesthetics

"The Hoka Silo X1 features a unique and interesting design that is visually appealing."

visuals

design

aesthetics

"The shoe is visually appealing with a nice design."

aesthetics

style

"The design of the Cellow X1 is noted to be aesthetically superior, making it visually appealing to runners."

design

aesthetics

visual appeal

"The shoes come in stylish color options, enhancing their aesthetic appeal."

color options

aesthetics

"The reflective upper enhances visibility and safety during runs."

reflective

safety

"The shoe manages to be lightweight despite its size, contributing to its overall performance during speed work."

performance

speed work

bulk

"The overall lightweight design of the shoe contributes positively to the running experience on varied surfaces."

lightweight

varied surfaces

positive experience

"The shoe offers a lightweight feel that enhances performance during races."

light

responsive

performance

"The shoe is unique in its appearance and construction, which may appeal to runners looking for something different."

design

style

innovation

"The shoe's vegan materials are a unique selling point for environmentally conscious consumers."

vegan

environmental impact

eco-friendly

"The Endorphin Pro 4 is noted for its good price-to-value ratio in the current market."

price

value

market

"The design of the shoe was visually appealing."

design

appearance

"Both shoes are described as versatile, making them suitable for various running workouts."

versatile

workouts

running

"Overall, reviewers found the shoe to be an impressive addition to their running experience, suitable for various types of runs."

great addition

impressive

variety

"The shoe has an exciting aesthetic appeal."

design

visual appeal

"Overall, the shoe provides a different and exciting running experience compared to others."

unique feel

exciting experience

"The shoe is designed to deliver a fun running experience, enhancing motivation."

fun

motivation

"Overall, personal preferences play a significant role in choosing between the two shoes."

personal preference

choice

"The visibility of the carbon plate in the Cellow X1 adds to its aesthetic charm, distinguishing it from competitors."

carbon plate

visibility

"The option to trial the shoes enhances customer confidence in purchasing."

trial policy

refund

"The HOKA Cielo X 1 is recommended for those looking for a quicker and firmer shoe for racing."

racing

firmer

super shoe

"The shoe maintains breathability while also providing warmth, suitable for cold weather conditions."

breathable

warmth

cold weather

Cons

"The shoe offers poor proprioception, making it difficult to gauge foot placement while running."

proprioception

awareness

"There is minimal ground feel, which affects responsiveness and connection with the running surface."

ground feel

responsiveness

"The laces are rigid and can become slippery, making it difficult to secure them properly."

laces

slippery

rigid

"The laces are poorly designed and difficult to use."

lace design

adjustability

"Laces may be cumbersome and less efficient for quick adjustments."

lace design

efficiency

race preparation

"The gift ribbon laces often come untied easily during runs."

laces

durability

"The laces are unconventional and may not suit everyone's preferences."

laces

styling

durability

"The laces of the SC Elite V4 are made of a poor material that is not ideal for performance."

laces

material

design

"The laces are considered low-quality and prone to coming undone."

laces

quality

secure

"The laces often come undone and are not very reliable."

laces

unstable

"The laces easily come undone and require a double knot to stay tied."

laces

stability

"The shoe's laces are difficult to manage, causing frustration during use."

management

frustration

"The shoe's design may not appeal to runners who prefer a more understated aesthetic."

design

aesthetics

"The shoe's colorway is considered overly extravagant and not appealing."

colorway

design

"The colorway of the shoe is unattractive."

color

design

"The price point of the shoe may be prohibitively high for some potential buyers."

price

expensive

"The price of the Cielo X1 may be prohibitive for some runners, especially considering it doesn't guarantee improved performance for everyone."

expensive

value

cost

"At $275, the shoe is considered overpriced for its performance and intended use."

expensive

value

"The shoe's high price point may not justify its performance compared to other brands."

price

value

"The price of the shoes could be a barrier for many potential buyers."

expensive

premium

"At $275, the shoe is considered too expensive for what it offers."

price

expensive

"The price is exceptionally high for many consumers."

price

value

"The shoe's price is deemed excessively high for its performance."

price

value

cost

"The shoe's price is prohibitively high, limiting access for many runners."

expensive

accessibility

"The price point of both shoes is described as absurd for some potential buyers."

price

value

cost

"The high price point of the shoes makes them inaccessible for many runners."

expensive

affordability

"The price of the Cellow X1 is considered too high for many runners."

expensive

affordability

"The price of the Skywood X, while less than the Cellow X1, is still considered quite high for a daily trainer."

expensive

premium

"The shoe is heavier than other racing shoes, which may deter some runners."

heavy

racing genre

running

comparative

"The shoe is on the heavier side, which may not appeal to some runners."

heaviness

marathon

disappointment

"Smaller runners may find the shoe to be heavier than expected."

weight

performance

"The shoe is considered heavy compared to other racing shoes."

weight

comparison

heaviness

"The shoe feels heavy for a carbon plate racing shoe."

heavy

carbon plate

"The shoe is heavier compared to its competitors in the super shoe market."

heavy

super shoe

comparison

"The shoe feels a bit heavy, especially for a women's size 8."

heavy

weight

size

"The shoe may not be the lightest option available."

weight

super shoe

"The shoes are heavier compared to rivals."

heaviness

comparison

"The shoe is considered heavy, which impacts its competitive edge."

weight

durability

"The weight of the shoe is a point of contention, as heavier shoes can be off-putting for some runners."

heaviness

preference

"The shoe may not be suitable for those who prioritize a lightweight experience in racing."

race day

lightweight

"The shoe's design allows for higher impact forces that could potentially lead to injuries."

bone_stress

super_shoes

performance

"The shoe is considered pricey at $275, which could deter some buyers."

price

expensive

investment

"The price of the shoe is considered high and not accessible to all runners."

expensive

affordability

"Breathability is just average, not groundbreaking."

average

decent

breathability

"The shoe's weight is significantly higher compared to other super shoes."

super shoe

weight

HOKA

"The shoe is heavy compared to other racers, which may adversely affect performance."

heavy

performance

"The shoe is heavier than expected for a super shoe."

lightness

performance

"The price of the shoe is higher than average and may not be justifiable for many runners."

price

super shoe

value

"The shoe is not suitable for runners looking for a lightweight option with good ground feel."

lightweight

fit

"At a high price point, runners might expect more robustness from the shoes."

price

expectation

"The price point is considered high compared to other options in the market."

high price

market comparison

cost

"The price point is high for a shoe that the reviewer feels does not reach top performance standards."

price

performance

value

"The price point of the shoe makes it a hard sell for many runners."

expensive

value

price point

"The shoe is positioned primarily for racing, which may limit its versatility for diverse running needs."

serious

race

"The shoe design includes an unusual colorway that may not appeal to everyone."

colorway

design

aesthetics

"The upper material feels outdated and unattractive."

material

aesthetics

outdated

"The shoe can be overly complex with too many elements that don't synergize well."

complexity

design

"The marketing hype may set unrealistic expectations."

marketing

expectations

"Some runners may struggle to accept the weight of the Hoka CX1."

weight

acceptance

"The shoe can feel a bit too big and cumbersome during long efforts."

cumbersome

headwind

"The shoe is designed as a racing shoe, and using it as an everyday trainer may not be its intended purpose."

price

training

"The shoelaces tend to come undone frequently due to the material they are made from, which is frustrating during runs."

shoelaces

annoyance

"The shoe feels late to the market with its cutout feature, suggesting a lack of innovation."

cutout

market position

"The Hoka C X1 has a heavier weight compared to the Endorphin Pro 4, which may be a detracting factor for some runners."

weight

heavy shoe

detraction

"The heel drop of 7 mm is considered high for a super shoe."

heel drop

high

super shoe

"The upper construction might contribute to the overall weight of the shoe."

upper construction

weight

thickness

"There’s a discrepancy in the heel height measurement, which could affect trust in the specs provided."

heel height

specs

measurement

"Limited information was available about the shoe before initial testing."

information

transparency

"The Hoka Cell X1 is recommended for beginners, hinting that it may not be suitable for advanced runners."

beginner

recommendation

marathon

"Concerns regarding the finish of the internal heel counter may be addressed in production models."

finish

production concern

Need help picking the right size?

Take a short quiz to help us find the right size for you compared to your current shoe. It takes 2 minutes.

Get started

Model Updates

Older Models

Newer Models

Reviews

Read reviews about the Hoka cielo x 1 from across the internet, including reviews from other runners on Fittir, wear testers from google & youtube, and more.

Reviews on Fittir (-)

...

Wear-tester reviews (80)

4.5/5

Prices

Find the best price for the Hoka cielo x 1 from across the internet with our partnered shoe retailers*.

Only null

We couldn't find any stock with our partners. Try searching google instead.

*When you click through to the retailer, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Its a great way to support us and keep this site free.

Similar Shoes

Most similar

Cheaper

More cushioned

Lighter

More responsive

Softer Cushion

Same brand

Different brand

Less cushioned

More expensive

New

Find out if the Hoka cielo x 1 is right for you.

Get a personalised running shoe recommendation based on your preferences and needs (free).

Get a recommendation

Hoka cielo x 1

Hoka cielo x 1

Surface

Cushioning

Category

Breathability

Weight

Heel-to-Toe Drop

Support

Width options

Grip

Suitability

Based on your running style and needs

Want to know if the Hoka cielo x 1 is right for you?

Pros & Cons

Most Mentioned Pros

Most Mentioned Cons

cushion

Pros

Cons

comfort

Pros

Cons

durability

Pros

Cons

performance

Pros

Cons

fit

Pros

Cons

stability

Pros

Cons

grip

Pros

Cons

other

Pros

Cons

Need help picking the right size?

Older Models

Newer Models

...

4.5/5

Similar Shoes

Find out if the Hoka cielo x 1 is right for you.